By Christopher Argent, founder, Generation CFO
I love a 2×2 matrix or four box grid, as it is such a simple way to communicate a host of data against two variables, from what to work on (Eisenhower Grid) to what suppliers to work with (Kraljic Matrix).
Here is another one, which focuses on BI tool user satisfaction and BI tool market presence. 
I like this matrix because the user’s voice counts more than any other metric (and not the IT consultants view on ease of implementation/execution, for example, or the vendors make believe roadmap that may or may not be relevant to the user.  Sorry Gartner!)
BI Grid
User satisfaction suggests buyers needs are being met or exceeded which is critical in tool selection, and market presence indicate not only a mature, tired and tested product, but more importantly, a user community that is feeding back and making suggestions and demand to tool owners to make them better.
The result, a list of leading BI tools users want to use, that’s you!  And for you techies, I have also added a note on Gartner’s 2×2 BI tools matrix, Feb 2018 (Ability to execute x Completeness of vision) to highlight the cream of the crop.
BI tool Leaders ordered by Satisfaction, with Gartner reference.

  1. InsightSquared
  2. Sisense
  3. Looker
  4. Domo
  5. Tableau (Gartner Leader)
  6. Power BI (Gartner Leader)
  7. Phocas
  8. WebFocus
  9. Board – also positioned as Corporate Performance Management software
  10. Qlik (Gartner Leader)
  11. MicroStrategy (Gartner Challenger)
  12. BusinessObjects
  13. Mode Analytics
  14. GoodData

So depending on your requirements, and how niche they are, I would consider all of the above, and as a general starter I would review Tableau, Power BI, Qlik and Board (due to its CPM/EPM/FP&A positioning).